In ten years working around penetration testing projects, I've read a lot of reports.
There's a particular kind that can make people relax when it should probably make them look a little closer.
No criticals. Maybe a couple of highs. A comfortable list of mediums and lows.
The sort of report that reaches a board meeting, gets a reassuring RAG status, and leaves everyone feeling that things are broadly under control.
The mediums get added to the backlog.
And some of them stay there for months.
The problem is that some of the most serious attack paths I've seen haven't started with a critical vulnerability at all.
They've been built from several individually unremarkable weaknesses which, when combined, give an attacker a route to something far more significant.
That's a big part of the offensive mindset Lewis Warner brings to our engagements at Koncise, and why attack paths are so important to how we're approaching Security Validation.
If testing stops at scoring individual findings, you can see the vulnerabilities without necessarily seeing the attack.
Severity scores describe findings. Attackers exploit paths.
CVSS is useful. It gives us a standardised way to describe the severity of an individual vulnerability.
But attackers don't experience an environment as a spreadsheet of isolated findings.
They chain weaknesses together. They pivot. They turn a relatively minor foothold into access to something far more important.
Imagine a simple sequence:
- Step one: An internet-facing application allows valid usernames to be identified.
- Step two: Authentication controls allow password-spraying attempts without effective throttling, lockout, or equivalent protections.
- Step three: One or more accounts use weak or predictable credentials.
- Step four: A compromised account has access to services or privileges that allow an attacker to move further into the environment.
Four Medium findings. One credible path to privileged access.
None of those weaknesses necessarily needs to represent a Critical vulnerability in isolation.
But in the right environment, combined weaknesses like these could provide a credible route from an unauthenticated attacker on the internet to meaningful internal access, lateral movement, or potentially highly privileged systems.
The findings haven't changed.
The understanding of the risk has.
And that's the important distinction.
The individual findings may remain Medium or lower severity, while the demonstrated attack path can represent a materially greater overall risk to the organisation.
Why does that matter?
Because remediation is often prioritised by severity.
Criticals first. Then highs. Mediums when there's time.
That's completely understandable, but it can mean the weakness that breaks an entire attack chain sits in the backlog simply because its individual score doesn't look particularly alarming.
Sometimes the most valuable fix in a report isn't the highest-scoring vulnerability.
It might be a Medium issue which, once addressed, breaks a significant attack path and prevents the attacker progressing further along it.
That's a much more useful conversation than simply handing an IT team forty findings and asking them to work from the top down.
It also makes the conversation with leadership clearer.
"We have several Medium findings" can be difficult to translate into business risk.
"We've demonstrated a credible attack path from an external foothold towards privileged internal access, and here are the controls that break that path" is much easier to understand and act on.
Same environment.
Much better understanding of the risk.
The question worth asking
So when your next penetration test arrives with a reassuring absence of Critical findings, there's another question worth asking:
Did anyone test what these findings can do together?
Because knowing what's vulnerable and understanding what an attacker can actually achieve are not quite the same thing.
That's a big part of how we're approaching Security Validation at Koncise.
We're less interested in producing a longer vulnerability list than the last provider, and more interested in identifying the attack paths that matter, demonstrating the controls that stop them, and helping clients understand where remediation effort will have the greatest impact.
Finding vulnerabilities is part of the job.
Understanding what they add up to is where the real value begins.
If you're reviewing your penetration testing approach, or planning your next assessment, we're always happy to compare notes.
Ready to start? Build your assessment and tell us what you need tested.
Koncise Solutions - Not your MSP. Not your Reseller. Your Cybersecurity Partner.
